Etsy
GiftoryCoDesign
“Personalized Ornaments, Coins & Tumblers | Holiday Gift”
The findings
Personalized Sunflower AA Medallion: Sobriety Coin, Recovery Gift
2 buyers reported a problem
sticker stuck on a brass coin
not an actual metal painted sunflower
Shop denies it.
coins are made with high-quality printing technology, not laser engraving
chip looks nothing like the photo
Shop denies it.
coins are made with high-quality printing technology, not laser engraving
Sobriety Challenge Coin: AA Recovery Brotherhood Sober Gift Medallion Token
2 buyers reported a problem
printed on paper and glued, not engraved
No reply from the shop.
back was not embossed just plain
No reply from the shop.
Custom Laser Engraved Travel Mug Black Stainless Steel 40oz
2 buyers reported a problem
design isn't centered on both sides
No reply from the shop.
shows gold look, received bronze look
No reply from the shop.
Personalized Sobriety Coin | Northern Lights AA Medallion
2 buyers reported a problem
sticker glued onto a cheap coin
No reply from the shop.
received a coin with no emblem
Shop accepts it.
Anniversary Gift for Husband Wife: Personalized Skeleton Love Coin Custom Names Date Gift
1 buyer reported a problem
not carved like all the pictures show
stickers on a coin blank
No reply from the shop.
Sobriety Coin: AA NA Jesus Faith Infinity Recovery Token Personalized Spiritual Christmas Gift 2025
1 buyer reported a problem
only 1 sided
supposed to have 2 sides printed
No reply from the shop.
Sobriety Coin for Women: AA NA Recovery Gift Personalized Spiritual Healing Light vs Dark Coin
1 buyer reported a problem
printed a little dark
not in the same place on both sides
No reply from the shop.
Sobriety Challenge Coin: AA Recovery Brotherhood Sober Gift Medallion Token
1 buyer reported a problem
didn't really expect it to just be a sticker
No reply from the shop.
not 3d looks cheap
No reply from the shop.
Goddammit Donut Challenge Coin: Princess Donut Fantasy Gamer Collectible Gift
1 buyer reported a problem
flat coin with a sticker on each side
No reply from the shop.
AA Sobriety Coin | Anchor Recovery Chip, Personalized Gift
1 buyer reported a problem
coin looks nothing like advertised
No reply from the shop.
Personalized Sobriety Coin | Tiger Bible Verse AA Medallion
1 buyer reported a problem
sticker glued onto a cheap coin
No reply from the shop.
Charlie Kirk Memorial Tumbler 40oz Travel Mug Patriotic Freedom Gift
1 buyer reported a problem
handle rubber peeling before use
No reply from the shop.
obvious typo in the quote
Shop accepts it.
stickers stuck to a metal disk
Shop denies it.
coins are made with high-quality printing technology, not laser engraving
Said more than once
- 2 buyers in 29 days reported: made a different way than the listing states, July 19, 2026 to August 17, 2026.
- 6 buyers in 69 days reported: made a different way than the listing states, June 09, 2026 to August 17, 2026.
- 5 buyers in 60 days reported: arrived visibly unlike the listing photo, September 21, 2025 to November 20, 2025.
- 3 buyers in 48 days reported: finish or legibility far below what was shown, September 18, 2025 to November 05, 2025.